From 276e2edc33ba67ce762dc10a522c07b419cd1429 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: JoseĢ Mota Date: Sun, 3 Jun 2012 13:07:33 +0100 Subject: Update some more posts. --- .../2011-12-26-a-perspective-on-education.markdown | 123 +++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 123 insertions(+) create mode 100644 _posts/2011-12-26-a-perspective-on-education.markdown (limited to '_posts/2011-12-26-a-perspective-on-education.markdown') diff --git a/_posts/2011-12-26-a-perspective-on-education.markdown b/_posts/2011-12-26-a-perspective-on-education.markdown new file mode 100644 index 0000000..800a8c8 --- /dev/null +++ b/_posts/2011-12-26-a-perspective-on-education.markdown @@ -0,0 +1,123 @@ +--- +layout: post +title: A perspective on the state of education (of the Web) +tags: [ design, personal improvementĀ ] +type: post +published: true +--- + +This is a [ challenge +](https://twitter.com/mollydotcom/status/147234090603651072) by [ Molly +Holzschlag ](http://molly.com) concerning how the Web is taught around here. +Even though I tend to be opinionated, things have been happening that I +consider important to a better future. + +Learning the craft of the Web has always been hard. It has taken a lot of +blog posts, trial and error, inspiration, books, etc. to slowly +progress; all of this... after hours. + +You must get things done at daytime. Innovation costs time that doesn't exist. +At least that's what most companies believe around here in the last 5 years. +Money is all leaders see, there's not the time nor the money to delve into a +better process or a better performance. Why bother if the pay is low and things +are steady? This is a cultural issue and that might just be the hardest +impediment that our people has to clear. + +## Academics is overrated + +Our culture has been dictating over the years that the path to success must +include a college degree. It even includes two now, a bachelor and a +masters degree. If you achieve none of them, people will think you're an idiot. +That immediately lowers any expectations for anyone that decides to hire a web +designer or an open source developer (i.e. not Java / .NET). That's +probably one of the many reasons why websites like Clients from Hell show up. We don't +have ECTS +to prove our clients we can do our job as much as those that do have them. + +The nature of the open web allows anyone to learn it and that is wonderful. +Resources are available everywhere, updated perhaps monthly. The community +gives their time, tutorials, references and screencasts. How will teachers +reassess innovative technologies such as HTML5, CSS3 and Javascript? What will +universities do with such a plethora of information? + +It's pretty hard to embrace all this change, so volatile. Trying to enclose an +everchanging engineering is hurtful for both the enclosed and the enclosing. +That's my #1 reason to believe that teaching the web isn't meant to be dominated by universities but by the community. + +## Education is underrated + +I took a Computer Science Engineering degree from 2004 to 2009. Everything I +know on how to be a web standards designer did not come from that degree. I +have learned every semantic element, every CSS best practice, every bit of +jQuery from home, after school. Professors lethargicly give students the +W3Schools' URL and that's it, they are not required to know more. However, they +are responsible for the future of website and web application development, +would they choose to. They ought to know more than simple divs and +some background colors. They are taught how to give birth to a full fledged, +top-to-bottom application, from database modeling and systems architecture to +basic MVC. It seems to me that the V is left a little alone. + +True education in its most pure and holistic meaning surpasses any established +rules. What matters is content and the apprentice's will to absorb it in the +way he feels it's best for him. Factory oriented learning — the one +that's implemented today from kindergarten to college — violates the +principle of individuality and it hurts growth. Sadly, achieving individuality +in the process of learning is utopic at this point in time and thus a +compromise must be reached. + +All we have now is the free Internet. People still keep learning and sharing +after hours (like I am right now). Twitter allows us to keep up with the +brightest mentors such as Molly herself, Andy Clarke, Jeffrey Zeldman, Jeremy Keith, Dan Cederholm, Chris Coyier, amongst so many inspired +people that blog and speak about design, standards and application development. +I owe them my career, certainly not my college degree. I'm pretty sure most +good portuguese designers feel the same way, even if ever so slightly. + +## Solutions + +I have stated before that universities shouldn't raise the flag and shape the +whole web standards industry. However, there is the room and the need to +solidify the basic assets of web development. In fact, I totally support the +creation (if not an update; perhaps a branch on W3C?) of a unique place where +all these resources can be served with quality documentation and possibility of +debate, allowing universities to have some sort of reference of what can be +introduced in their courses and promote the best content to their students. +This not only: + +* Gives future designers and developers' the right skills and techniques so + they can do their job like they never did before; but also, +* Increases the universities' reputation for their investment in practical, + meaningful content that helps students get things done fast and done well. + +A great example of a standardized way of centering resources in one accessible +and friendly place is the Rubygems platform. +Unlike other programming languages, Ruby has managed to flagpole an idea so +great and no other language has ever made it this well. Sure, PEAR for PHP is nice and CTAN for LaTeX is huge but not has rewarding +and simple as the gem system. Everyone uses Rubygems, all the tools for +publishing Ruby knowledge are published through it; it builds trust amongst the +developer community and it's just amazing. + +The effort of standardizing education of the web is being debuted in Portugal +with the birth of a post-graduation in Web design at ESAD. Tiago Pedras et al have been working hard +so as to build a course that grants you ECTS points and also means something. I +look forward to hear from him and acknowledge that finally the bar is being +raised for everyone. + +## Conclusion + +After several years, our nation is finally taking its first steps to adulthood +regarding the craft of the web. Up until now, every designer was a nomad +messing around with what they thought they knew and stuck with it. Now there's +a chance for constantly embracing change and be happy about it. Let's look at +what has been done well in the last few years and consider the chance of making +the world a better place through creativity and care, one step at a time. -- cgit v1.2.3-54-g00ecf